Wednesday, May 2, 2012

long-windedness and Sayers

Linking to the page that I'm supposed to read and write about.

I find the author extremely long-winded and rambling.  What she is trying to say could be said in fewer words and with a great deal more clarity, IMHO.

BUT, that being said, I'm not here to critique her writing; I'm here to discuss her premise.  That is topic I will tackle in my application to the school, and the one I will post here:

First of all, Sayers is obviously correct in her statement that it takes much longer for children today to reach maturity than they did in the medieval times.  Back then, it wasn't unusual for a male to go to college in his early teens, yet today, many teenagers are pampered in a state of luxurious limbo.  Is it really because there is so much more to learn today than a long time ago?  Perhaps, but I find that we are turning out numerous jacks-of-all-trades and masters of none.  Instead of delving into anything worthwhile, our youth are taught mere skimmings from the tops of a multitude of subjects.

Reminded me of this quote:
“With school turning out more runners, jumpers, racers, tinkerers, grabbers, snatchers, fliers, and swimmers instead of examiners, critics, knowers, and imaginative creators, the word 'intellectual,' of course, became the swear word it deserved to be.” ~ Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451

Sayers continues that despite our growing "knowledge",students today are unable to distinguish basic fact from fiction, and are continuously caught up in a web of lies spun by the media.  And she wrote this in the 1940's!  Imagine what she would say if she could see the media circus today - when the tabloids often have the most reliable articles!  (I'm not kidding about that!)  But I should not say "students", for today is it the average person of any age.  One has only to watch the presidential debates (Go Ron Paul!) to watch how facts are distorted and emotions are played.  Even supposedly intelligent people are taken in by the passionate pleas of the politicians (alliteration rocks!).

Her solution to the problem is long and you can read it for yourself.  But it is basically a return to the medieval education system of the Trivium, which teaches children how to think, how to grasp language, and how to form arguments, instead of mindlessly parroting everything they hear.  We send the students out into the world only half-prepared at best.  A firm grasp of Latin (and here I completely agree with her, since I credit my study of Latin as the reason I scored high on the Verbal SAT) opens up all the doors of the Romance languages as well as facilitates study of English.

I agree with Sayers in nearly everything I read.  Early childhood should be a time of gathering facts and building a foundation for the subjects of later years.  Middle childhood is when this knowledge should be analyzed and discussed - it is not enough to know the date and signers of the Magna Carta, but why it was vital to our current system of government today.  Too often this Dialectic stage is overlooked in our schools, and mere facts are retained by the students, but without this vital middle step, we send our children into the world wholly unprepared for the challenges that face them.




No comments:

Post a Comment